
Saturday, 10 April 2010
A New Club
Tuesday, 23 March 2010
The Best Secondary Reinforcer of All...
(I’ll try and make this comment brief because if you’re like me, this is just one of a L-O-N-G list of training and behaviour blogs you want to read today!)
When I rescued my first deaf dog, the secondary reinforcer had to be something visual instead of my normal verbal one. With deaf dogs it’s usually a hand signal such as a thumbs-up or some other obvious hand movement. To cut a long story short, after a while I noticed that my dog was starting to show less and less interest in the secondary reinforcer, and even in the primary reinforcer (in this case, food). I just couldn’t understand what was going on; my timing was good, I was being consistent. Perhaps the withdrawal into an intermittent reward schedule was too quick? So I upped the schedule and to my surprise my dog ignored me even MORE!
What the hell was going on?
Then I noticed something… My dog had stopped looking at my face. She had almost no interest in me whatsoever when there were distractions in the environment, no matter WHAT food I was offering as a reward. Another thing I noticed was that if we were playing a game without offering any rewards, she was much more engaged and animated.. The penny dropped. I had become so reliant on my thumbs-up as the secondary reinforcer I had stopped saying ‘Good Girl’.
When I had stopped saying ‘Good Girl’, I had stopped smiling.
My deaf dog was denied a smile when I was rewarding her with food, simply because I'd fallen out of the habit.
Within a couple of days of reintroducing the bright and shiny ‘Good Girl!’ with a bright and shiny smile, she was as keen as mustard again.
I thought this was just a deaf dog problem… Oh if only.
Over the years since I’ve been watching the development of positive reinforcement training with joy; just so thankful that we have evolved beyond pain and coercion to shape behaviours (well, some of us anyway…)
Gradually I started picking out a pattern where secondary reinforcers such as clickers and verbal markers were not always motivating the dog; in fact with some dogs it looked as if they were thoroughly fed up of them.
Then I spotted it; or rather couldn’t spot it… It hit me like a waft of wiffy kippers!
Where was the EMOTION? Where was the smiling eye contact? The bright shiny voice? The physical animation from the handler?!
The clicker / verbal marker / hand signal had somehow suppressed the emotional response from the handler!! Suddenly I was seeing this all over the place – dogs switching off because their handlers had become emotional vacuums when in ‘training mode’. The trainers were on automatic pilot and weren’t even aware that their faces, voices and bodies had become devoid of emotion and more importantly, joy.
It made so much sense to me; we expect our dogs to be happy to work with us, to show enjoyment, to have wagging tails when we’re training, especially now we’re on the positive reinforcement train (yes, pun intended), but where was OUR joy? But how on earth were our dogs supposed to be joyful when their role models (us) had become as emotional as your average yard broom??!
So I’ve been testing this theory, ‘geeing’ up handlers that haven’t even noticed that their faces, voices and bodies have become emotionless, making them skip, jump, hop, smile, laugh as well as give their normal markers. I’ve been working on them injecting the joy back into their training and BOY is it making a difference!! We’ve got dogs GALLOPING back to their skipping owners! We’ve got owners finding the children in themselves again and rediscovering the JOY in being with their dogs! It’s simply awe-inspiring to see the happiness flooding back into people’s faces, voices and body language and this being mirrored in the responses of their dogs.
So, I’m hoping the take-home message here is that the best secondary reinforcer of all is Joy. Don’t let a clicker or a ‘Good Dog’ ever replace it.
Monday, 22 February 2010
Teddy's Blog - Day 5
Sunday, 21 February 2010
Teddy's Blog - Day 4
And you thought I was going to say our Teddy had turned into some snarling monster... Have some faith, people!
The fantastic thing about Ted though is that he learned in about two instances that if he picked something up and brought it to me, I would exchange it for a small piece of food. By the end of the day he was picking up random items, bringing them to me with a 'Sit' and releasing them on command. No conflict, no chasing him to retrieve the odd sock or dropped piece of paper out of his mouth, no pulling jaws open or holding him down. I've never fostered a gundog before and it's honestly been a joy to live with a dog that has such an intelligence about his mouth; working with mastiffs is a WHOLE different ballgame!
We've been playing fetch with a toy indoors but somewhere along the line Teddy's been taught to tug for competition. Such a shame because he'd have so much more fun retrieving and releasing but he hasn't learned that yet. We'll work on this a bit more but the best thing to do with a dog that refuses to give it up is drop your end of the toy. Repeatedly and immediately he pulls on it. Poor Ted was a bit confused as he is used to the human end of the toy being a bit more obstinate and competitive!
Saturday, 20 February 2010
Teddy's Blog - Day 3
He's a wee bit jittery on night walks but confident, calm handling and a 'Walk On' command, that's all he needs
Friday, 19 February 2010
Teddy's Blog - Day 2
More on Ted, with hopefully some pics, tomorrow.
Thursday, 18 February 2010
Foster Dog Blog - Teddy
Friday, 5 February 2010
Dog Adoption and Follow Up Support
I was in the office working today when I received a call from someone who had a problem with their dog that they had adopted from a local rescue a few months ago.
Whenever I am told that the dog has come from a rescue organisation my first question is always “Have you contacted the rescue to see if they can offer some support from their behaviourist?”.
When I asked this question today, I was told that the rescue was a very ‘ramshackle’ place and it was extremely unlikely they would have a consultant behaviourist.
This isn’t the first time I’ve heard this and I know it won’t be the last. I find it deeply disturbing that rescues are still not signing up a behaviourist or trainer to assist with post-adoption support and advice, leaving adopters having to find third-party support, sometimes from very dubious people calling themselves behaviourists or trainers but who have actually only watched a couple of TV shows or read a few books, or who are vets with no behavioural qualifications…
I have the very unusual perspective of being the coordinator of a breed rescue as well as having a professional behaviour consultancy which, amongst other activities, assists with the assessment of rescue dogs from other organisations. I just can’t imagine not being able to provide advice to adopters when they run into trouble after the honeymoon period of a couple of weeks. It’s so important for owners to realise that the rescue is there to help them KEEP their dog, not just offer to take it back and rehome it yet again.
Most small rescues will not be able to afford a good in-house behaviourist but surely it is then in a rescue organisation’s best interests to source an external behaviourist to refer their adopters onto if there are problems rather than just leave the owner (and the rescue dog they have placed) in trouble?
There are many, many qualified, experienced behaviourists and trainers out there who would be more than willing to assist rescue organisations by taking on post-adoption referrals.
Take us up on this, rescues!
Go out and look up some behaviourists, get them in for a chat and see how they work, check out their qualifications and experience, look up if they are a member of a professional organisation and if they are used to working with rescue dogs. Ask if they would be willing to offer a reduced rate to the owners to work with your post-adoptive dogs; I do!
Times are changing and it’s no longer acceptable for rescues to simply do the homecheck and release the dog. Aftercare is so, so important and by simply providing a resource where owners can go to if they are having problems might just reduce the ‘bounce’ rate of returned dogs to rescue…
Sunday, 24 January 2010
MY take on Milan & Shadow...
Friday, 22 January 2010
Dog Breeding - Again
- Reminding me that I own / have owned pedigree breeds myself so therefore must agree with selective breeding and accept that all dogs would be mongrels without breeders.
- Saying they are confused by my statement that I do not support selective breeding, but then say that work needs to be done on improving the behaviour of dogs.
- Individual breeders taking great pains to inform me of the careful selections they make when putting dogs together, suggesting that these actions are the only way to improve the health of dogs…
Thursday, 14 January 2010
Dog Breeding in the UK
The report can be downloaded and read by clicking the link above so I won't discuss the whole 64 page report. I do however want to say things about some of the findings presented as many of them I recognise as laments of those of us working 'at the sharp end' of breeders' mistakes!
I am no fan of selective breeding or showing for very definite reasons; the minute either ego or money enters the equation, the worst possible side of humanity shows through. If animals are involved, they are the innocent victims and I'm really pleased that this report is quite strongly-worded in places regarding the lack of integrity they have noted in breeders, albeit accompanied by the disclaimer that this is a generalisation and does not apply to all, of course.
That common motivator should be animal welfare, but unfortunately as previously said, ego and money are often the primary motivators in dog breeding and showing and I believe that these are mutually exclusive to canine welfare.
Wednesday, 6 January 2010
The Sense of Loss...
Tuesday, 29 December 2009
Denial isn't just a river in Africa....
I was out with Sticky & Bailey yesterday afternoon in our village fields enjoying a lovely, quiet, uneventful walk with my four-legged friends when, a long-haired GSD flew out of the bushes and lunged at Sticky’s back. I was about 10m away which isn’t normally a problem in this normally blissfully peaceful environment, but I knew I wouldn’t be able to get there for a few seconds. I was therefore very proud of little Sticky (Lab x Dachshund) who managed a neat trick of combining just enough appeasement with just enough warning behaviour to keep things from escalating into a fight (I believe this is due to the time spent in an Irish pound having to learn these life skills…)
I don’t tend to panic in these situations because, well, to be honest I’ve seen some horrendous dog fights and it does a marvellous job of desensitising you to the normal ‘handbags-at-dawn’ type squabble that domestic pet dogs tend to have; it’s actually dealing with the humans involved afterwards that normally gets my blood pressure to nuclear levels.
I did a couple of deep yells and then I heard the owner (previously hidden on the path behind the bushes) yelling at his dog and come crashing through waving a stick at it. He grabbed his poor dog who by this time was beside itself with panic and literally throttled it. I called Sticks to me and found that although he had a few tooth-scrapes in his fur and a bit of slobber on him, was otherwise physically okay.
“Sorry about that – I didn’t see you were there” the owner replied, holding his petrified dog so tightly I thought it was going to pass out.
“What was that about?” I asked the owner calmly as I examined Sticky.
“Dunno” he replied blandly with a shrug.
“Has it done that before?” I said, knowing full-well that this was an established behaviour.
“Nope – never” he said, not that convincingly.
“Look, I do this for a living and work with dogs like this almost every day; that was quite an established display.”
“Are you calling me a liar?” said the owner in an all-too-familiar kneejerk reaction.
“I don’t have to – your dog has just told me all I need to know.”
To save his poor dog any further pain I started to walk away but as calmly as possible asked the owner to get some help for his dog before it was too late and advised him that now his dog had now ‘attacked’ another once – not to let it happen again. We both knew this wasn’t the first time the dog had done this but I thought it might be worth pretending to be in denial as deeply he was just to get a serious message across…
The owner said nothing more and dragged his dog off in the opposite direction.
What struck me hardest about this incident was how ineffectual this owner was with his dog and how easily this kind of problem can be resolved. Luckily the dog has good ‘ABI’ (Acquired Bite Inhibition) or we’d have had to stitch poor Sticky up like a patchwork quilt, but it seemed obvious to me that this dog is crying out for his owner to write the Rulebook and be his Referee, not let him wander around feeling anxious and lost enough to just launch himself at passing dogs.
As an example, once I’d released Sticky after examining him he went to trot back up to the GSD, who had by now shut down completely and was just sitting there with a glazed look in his eyes, still held far too tightly by the collar. I merely said ‘No’ in a calm, firm voice, called Sticks back and he stopped and came back immediately, which he was praised for with a smile and a wink and a ‘Good Lad’. Our rulebook says when I say ‘No’, Sticky stops. Our rulebook says when I say ‘Sticks Come’, Sticky comes back. Our rulebook says he gets a wink and a smile and even – sometimes – a treat for following the rules. He knows I’ll enforce it if I have to. He knows where he stands. It’s a nicer place to be for a dog. And an owner.
I hope the GSD gets the help he needs and the incident yesterday proves to be a turning point in his life.
Sticky, by the way, is physically okay but a bit unsettled today. After a bit of a shock like this and the subsequent adrenalin rush, it can take a dog a couple of days to get back to a normal maintenance state. At least he’s in the right place for the help he needs to recover. I find myself wondering if the poor GSD will get the same or whether his owner still thinks denial is just a river in Africa…
Thursday, 24 December 2009
Nature v Nurture
I’ve been watching an interesting thread on a dog forum with pro-bull breeds and anti-bull breeds ‘discussing’ whether these dogs make good family pets. This has been my response today…
Its the age-old question of nature v nurture. BOTH should be considered in the temperament of a dog (or any animal). Breeds historically (and currently, tragically) bred for fighting will have had the most 'gamey' specimens used for selected breeding and this will be a factor in their temperament down the line unless those characteristics have been specifically bred out.
However, what most people forget is that it is just as easily achieved to 'breed in' aggression with dogs that were never used for fighting, simply by naive breeders selecting for aesthetics rather than soundness of temperament. I have temperament assessed and worked with many dogs of differing breeds over the years and believe me, there are some breeds and lines of dogs previously known for their docility that are becoming more prone to display aggression, yet it's only the stereotyped breeds that make the headlines...
Sunday, 6 December 2009
A game of Chicken or Dare...
I had an interesting run in today with a dog in our village that is well known for being out of it’s yard and out of control with no owners in sight.
It’s a little beagle / basset cross female who has, in the past hurtled across one of the village green areas from outside it’s house and aggressed at dogs passing by.
I’ve already had a ‘run-in’ with the owner in the past; a delightful woman who behaved much like her dog except the effect was much muted by the fact she was dressed in her pyjamas and dressing gown at 1pm in the afternoon…
Well this poor little dog was again out this afternoon as I took my two for their run up in the fields. We spotted each other from a distance and, predictable as clockwork, she came hurtling around the corner, hackles upright and ready for action.
What she hadn’t expected was that I was standing there waiting for her.
With my (onlead) dogs BEHIND me (so they understood that I was dealing with this, not them,) I stood full square, pointed at her, glared and calmly growled “DON’T”…
I wish I’d had a video because she skidded to a halt, her tail went so far under her legs that it could have tickled her chin and she immediately dropped to the floor, turned quietly away and skulked back off around the corner.
Round one to me…
About an hour later I wondered if we would have a repeat performance on our way back from the fields.
As I approached ‘her’ territory I looked across and saw her sitting outside her gate, I presume still waiting for someone to let her into her yard (it was by now raining… poor soul).
She looked at me.
I looked at her.
I raised one finger and glared at her.
She looked away calmly and stayed where she was.
Round two and the match to me…
Thursday, 26 November 2009
Just for owners of Dachsies & Terriers...
I was studying today (psychopharmacology) and came across this pearl of wisdom that is SO obvious it made me laugh…
“Digging may be a nuisance but it is an innate trait for many dogs. Terriers and Dachshunds were bred to flush out prey or to locate rodents in underground areas where digging is required.”
No kidding!!! Anybody that has a terrier or a Dachsie or crosses thereof will laugh as I did… Unless they’re exhibiting their digging skills in your prize-winning begonia beds of course!
Wednesday, 25 November 2009
Dog / Dog Greetings
We were walking towards a pair of Weimaraners who were offlead with their owner. As we approached one of them came forward to approach us. Sticky did the same thing but then hesitated. He had sensed something not right. He paused, gave some very clear ‘cut off’ signalling to the other dog/s and looked back at me. I smiled at him and said ‘Good boy Sticks’ to reinforce his peaceful actions instead of flying upto them out of control.
As we got closer he approached the Weimaraner pair and everything seemed pretty okay; lots of mutual bottom sniffing and wheeling around each other. Sticks then pottered off peacefully. By this time Bailey and I had caught up. I always hold her collar quietly and accompany her up to other dogs just so that she approaches gently and doesn’t alarm them by running upto them.
I then became aware of why Sticky had paused. The male Weimaraner was in an extreme state of arousal. His pupils were almost fully dilated, his hackles were up all the way along his neck to the base of his tail, his movements were stiff and deliberate and his general behaviour was far from relaxed and friendly.
Instead of calmly scenting Bailey, he immediately launched himself onto her shoulders, pushing her down. She responded by playbowing and jumping to appease him as she could obviously sense his ‘tone’ too. Far from appeasing and encouraging to play, he became even more agitated, trying to stand over her, shoulder-barge her and pounding on her shoulders and neck again and again. I then realised that the owner was not going to step in so calmly stood between them, helping poor Bailey out and providing a barrier for her as she had become stressed by this wildly inappropriate behaviour. The owner then said ‘oh he does this – I have to be careful with him’, grabbed him and pulled him away.
I said nothing more and simply trotted on with Bailey, wanting to help her recover quickly from this ‘thug-mugging’, which she did within a few minutes.
The owner knows… that’s who.
She KNOWS there was a problem with this dog’s reaction to other dogs but instead of dealing with this situation promptly, calmly and with some authority, she allowed him to continue his mugging uninterrupted until I stepped in. She KNOWS there is a problem with this dog but allows him offlead around others.
It’s this kind of owner that gives the rest of us a bad name; someone that KNOWS deep down there is a problem but is in denial, allowing their dog to practice their behaviour unchecked and without getting any kind of help. It is the dog I feel sorry for. One day it is going to mug the wrong dog, end up seriously hurt and it will be his owner, the one who should be guiding him and leading him through life, who must carry the blame – but she won’t. She will blame the owner of the other dog. Scary, isn’t it?